Should an Australian service business use an AI receptionist or an offshore receptionist?
Often both, with different jobs. An AI receptionist is cheap and answers at any hour, so it suits after-hours calls, overflow and simple bookings. A person suits complaints, judgement calls and bookings that need context. We found no independent accuracy benchmark for AI receptionists, and most published comparisons come from AI phone vendors.
This guide is for tradies, clinics, law firms and similar businesses where the phone is how work arrives. We sell offshore staff, so weigh our view accordingly. Every source below is labelled as a vendor, a secondary report or our own estimate, and figures we could not trace are left out.
What can an AI receptionist handle well, and where does it fall short?
It handles the routine well and the unusual badly. Table 1 is our assessment, built from what vendors themselves say their products can and cannot do.
Table 1: Who handles what: AI receptionist, offshore receptionist, or both
| Call or task | AI receptionist | Offshore receptionist | Our view |
| After-hours and overflow calls | Answers instantly at any hour and takes the name, number, reason and urgency | Only on a shifted roster or a second person, which costs more | AI first |
| Simple bookings against a calendar | Works when connected to your booking system; vendors charge for further integrations | Works, with access to your calendar | Either; AI suits the volume |
| Routine questions (hours, location, service area) | Handles well | Handles well | AI during overflow, a person in hours |
| Complaints and upset callers | Weak: vendors themselves list empathy as a limit | Strong, with training and a clear escalation path | A person, first |
| Urgent or safety-critical calls (burst pipe, chest pain) | Only with set keywords that alert the owner at once | A person can judge urgency and call the owner | Both: alert rules plus a person |
| Quotes and bookings that need context | Limited; struggles with messy problems across several systems | Handles well with notes and system access | A person |
| Long-standing or high-value clients | Cannot offer long-standing clients warmth, per one vendor guide | Handles well | A person |
| Walk-ins and deliveries | Cannot do | Cannot do | Keep in-person reception local |
Source: our assessment, informed by VOCPhone's guide to AI answering (14 Jul 2026) and Binary Elements' BE Voice page (updated 4 Nov 2026). Both sell AI phone products. We have not tested these products, and this is a judgement, not a measured result.
Vendors are candid about the edges. VOCPhone's guide says AI "can't feel", cannot offer long-standing clients warmth, struggles with messy problems across several systems and does not greet walk-ins. Binary Elements says its product does not replace the rest of what a person on the desk does. Neither publishes an accuracy rate, and the OAIC warns that AI systems are known to produce inaccurate or false results, so keep a person in the loop.
We also found no independent Australian figure for how many calls small businesses miss. Vendor pages say "well over half" without naming a source, so we do not use missed-call or lost-revenue numbers.
What do callers say about talking to AI?
They accept it for routine tasks and want a person when it matters. Table 2 collects the evidence we could verify, nearly all of it from vendors.
Table 2: What callers say about talking to AI, 2025 and 2026
| Measure | Latest figure | Source and date | Caveat |
| Australians who try to bypass AI agents to reach a person | 83%, spending an average of 101 seconds trying | Twilio 2026 Customer Insights Series, reported by B&T, 27 Oct 2026 (7,652 consumers in 18 markets; fieldwork 9 Apr to 1 May 2026) | Vendor research about AI agents in general, not receptionists; Australian sample size not stated |
| Time saved by AI agents | 63 seconds on average, a net loss of 38 seconds once the bypass attempt is counted | Twilio, via B&T | As above; how time was measured is not stated |
| Comfort with AI doing routine tasks | 70% for scheduling appointments, 71% for processing a return, 68% for a dinner reservation; 42% for handling a medical inquiry or making a payment | Twilio, via B&T | Self-reported; shows acceptance of routine, low-risk tasks |
| Wanting to be told it is AI | 89% want to be explicitly told when they are interacting with AI | Twilio, via B&T | Self-reported |
| Choosing a chatbot to resolve an issue | 2% would choose a chatbot; 55% favour email | Sinch, reported by CMOtech, 25 Nov 2025 | Sample, dates and survey firm not stated |
| Escalation gap | 86% expect AI tools to hand unresolved issues to a person; 38% see that regularly | Zoom, with Morning Consult, reported by IT Brief Australia, 14 Aug 2025 | Over a year old; Australian sample size not stated |
| Text chatbot against voicebot | In some situations a text chatbot produced more relief than a voicebot | Associate Professor Felix Septianto, University of Queensland Business School, opinion piece, 2 Sep 2026 | No sample given; the underlying studies are not confirmed |
| Telling callers it is AI | Associated with about 20% fewer hang-ups; mentioning recording with about 30% fewer; greetings that lead with the owner being unavailable with about 50% more | Upfirst, an AI answering vendor, analysis of 450,702 calls across 503 AI receptionists, updated 16 Jun 2026 | Observational; country, industries and period not stated; the author says setup choices explain only about 13% of the gap |
| A large bank reversing cuts after a voice bot | Commonwealth Bank reversed 45 customer service job cuts and said its assessment was an error | HRD Australia, 21 Aug 2025 | The rising call volumes are the union's claim; a bank is not a small service business |
Sources: B&T (Twilio, 27 Oct 2026); CMOtech (Sinch, 25 Nov 2025); IT Brief Australia (Zoom and Morning Consult, 14 Aug 2025); University of Queensland Business School (2 Sep 2026); Upfirst (16 Jun 2026); HRD Australia (21 Aug 2025). Twilio, Sinch, Zoom and Upfirst sell communications or AI software. We read news coverage and vendor pages, not the primary reports. No study here measured AI receptionists in small businesses.
In Twilio's survey 70% of Australians were comfortable with AI scheduling an appointment, yet 83% tried to bypass an AI agent, and the 101 seconds spent doing so outweighed the 63 seconds the AI saved. A University of Queensland researcher, Associate Professor Felix Septianto, wrote in September that a text chatbot sometimes drew better reactions than a voicebot, which matters for a phone product.
The Commonwealth Bank reversed 45 customer service job cuts in August 2025 after introducing a voice bot, and admitted its assessment was an error. The union said call volumes had been rising. A bank is not a plumber, but software that takes the easy calls can leave a harder queue for people. None of these studies measured AI receptionists in small businesses.
What does each option cost?
AI is far cheaper per year, but it is not a like-for-like swap. Table 3 gives the price and pay evidence and Table 4 gives our model.
Table 3: Price and pay evidence: AI answering plans and Australian receptionist pay, 2026
| Measure | Latest figure | Source and date | Caveat |
| AI answering, VOCPhone | Self-serve A$49 to A$149 a month; managed A$149 to A$499 a month | VOCPhone, an Australian cloud phone vendor, 14 Jul 2026 | Vendor list prices; watch per-minute charges above the plan caps; its human-receptionist cost table is not used |
| AI answering, Binary Elements BE Voice | About 27.5c a minute with no plan; Starter A$149 a month with 200 minutes, then 45c; Business A$299 a month with 600 minutes, then 40c; add-ons from about A$62 a month; month to month | Binary Elements, page updated 4 Nov 2026 (ex GST) | Vendor list prices; the first integration is free, further ones are quoted separately |
| Receptionist pay, Robert Half | A$65,000 to A$70,000 gross, with a median of A$65,000 | Robert Half Australia salary guide page for receptionists, updated 27 Mar 2026 | Excludes super and bonuses; guide edition not named; no city benchmark |
| Medical receptionist pay, Employment Hero | Median A$58,000; typical range A$51,000 to A$65,000 | Employment Hero medical receptionist guide, updated Oct 2026 | Base pay only; proprietary data; its own percentile chart labels A$65,000 as the median, so we used the text |
| Local and offshore rates in our guide | Local customer service rep A$50,000 to A$65,000; virtual assistant A$55,000 to A$65,000; offshore customer service rep A$1,300 a month, virtual assistant A$1,400 a month | Our Philippines salary guide, 29 Jun 2026 | Our own page; it has no receptionist row, so our model uses the virtual assistant rate as a stand-in |
Sources: VOCPhone; Binary Elements; Robert Half Australia; Employment Hero; Pear Tree's Philippines salary guide. SEEK's receptionist salary page would not load for us. Vendor prices change often. Our model uses A$60,000, between the Employment Hero and Robert Half medians.
Table 4: Modelled annual cost: AI answering, a local receptionist and an offshore receptionist
| Option | Modelled annual cost | What it assumes | Caveat |
| AI answering, plan fees only | A$1,788 (Starter) to A$3,588 (Business); A$5,988 at the top managed price | BE Voice Starter A$149 and Business A$299 a month; VOCPhone managed A$499 a month, ex GST | Covers 200 to 600 minutes a month; extra minutes cost more |
| AI answering every call (illustrative) | A$7,836 (Starter) or A$7,044 (Business) | Our volume assumption: 20 calls a day, 3 minutes each, 22 days, so 1,320 minutes a month; Starter A$149 plus 1,120 minutes at 45c; Business A$299 plus 720 minutes at 40c | Our assumption, not data; not a like-for-like swap for a person |
| Local receptionist, steady state | A$81,242 (A$69,000 small-business variant) | A$60,000 salary, super 12%, NSW payroll tax 5.45%, workers' compensation 1%, a desk at A$715 a month, A$1,200 equipment | The small-business variant has no desk and sits below the payroll tax threshold |
| Local receptionist, first year | A$93,242 | Steady state plus A$1,200 extra first-year equipment and an 18% recruitment fee (A$10,800) | The 18% fee is our assumption within a typical range |
| Offshore receptionist, 12 months | A$22,800 | A$1,400 monthly rate plus the flat A$400 monthly management fee (A$21,600), plus A$1,200 of software | Excludes the one-time placement fee, which is unpublished; business hours only |
| Offshore receptionist plus AI overflow | A$24,588 | Offshore A$22,800 plus the Starter plan at A$1,788, if AI takes 200 minutes or fewer a month | Our assumption; busier overflow adds per-minute charges |
Source: Pear Tree's own model, an estimate and not independent data. The admin/VA row stands in for a receptionist. In steady state a local hour costs about A$49 (1,664 productive hours) against about A$15 offshore (1,498 hours after a 10% productivity discount). The offshore figure is 72% below the local steady-state figure and 67% below the small-business variant.
AI minutes add up. At our illustrative volume of 20 calls a day, a per-minute plan costs about A$7,000 a year, because plans include only 200 to 600 minutes. A person costs more because a person does more: greeting, chasing, calming and deciding. The offshore receptionist is about 72% below the local steady-state cost, before the one-time placement fee. Small employers below the payroll tax threshold with no desk save less.
For pay we used A$60,000, between Employment Hero's A$58,000 medical receptionist median and Robert Half's A$65,000 receptionist median. SEEK's page would not load for us.
What does an offshore receptionist actually cover?
Business-hours calls, bookings, messages and follow-ups, on a roster you set. A Philippines-based receptionist on a shifted roster of about 6am to 3pm Manila time covers a Sydney 9am to 6pm day during daylight saving, because Manila is three hours behind. After-hours human cover costs more, since it needs a second person or a split roster.
A South Africa-based agent's ordinary 8am to 5pm lands in Australian evening, 5pm to 2am Sydney time, and our rates are the same in both markets. In the EF English Proficiency Index 2025 the Philippines ranked 28th and South Africa 13th, though that is a self-selected online test, so audition any candidate on real calls with your own scripts.
A remote receptionist cannot greet walk-ins or sign for deliveries, so a clinic with a waiting room still needs someone on site. Under the Privacy Act's APP 8 and section 16C you stay accountable for how overseas staff handle personal information, so use a written contract, least-privilege access, two-factor authentication and a VPN.
What do you have to tell callers, and can you record the call?
Tell callers it is AI, and tell them if you record. In Twilio's survey 89% want to be told when they are dealing with AI, and a vendor's analysis of 450,702 calls linked disclosure with fewer hang-ups, though it is observational and does not state the country or period.
On recording, a law firm's 2025 summary says NSW, the ACT, SA and WA generally need all parties' consent, while Queensland, Victoria, Tasmania and the Northern Territory generally allow one-party recording. The conservative approach is clear notice at the start of every call, so check the current Acts. The OAIC says businesses should update privacy policies and notifications with clear information about AI use, and that due diligence on an AI product should not be "set and forget". It also recommends against entering personal information into public generative AI tools, which matters for clinics and law firms. This is general information, not legal advice.
How should the two work together?
Give each the job it does best, with a clear handover. Let AI answer after hours and when the desk is busy, take the name, number, reason and urgency, and say plainly that it is AI. Offer a route to a person, and set urgent words such as burst pipe or chest pain to alert the owner at once. Have a person return complaints first, and review the AI's call summaries weekly.
Start with a month of overflow only, then compare answered calls and complaints before changing the desk. A sole trader taking about 30 calls a month does not need a full-time receptionist of either kind. AI answering or a part-time arrangement is the better fit.
The bottom line for Australian service businesses
Use AI where speed and hours matter, and a person where judgement matters. Pear Tree places directly hired offshore customer service and administrative staff from the Philippines and South Africa for a one-time placement fee plus a flat $400 a month per hire. We sell offshore staff, so test any claim, ours included, against your own call logs.
Frequently asked questions
Can an AI receptionist replace a human receptionist?
Not entirely. AI answers instantly at any hour and handles routine calls and simple bookings. People remain better at complaints, urgent judgement calls and bookings that need context, and neither option can greet walk-ins. We found no independent accuracy benchmark for AI receptionists, so we suggest AI for after-hours and overflow calls and a person for the rest.
How much does an AI receptionist cost in Australia?
On vendor list prices, from about A$49 to A$499 a month at VOCPhone, and from A$149 for 200 minutes or A$299 for 600 minutes at Binary Elements, with extra minutes at 40c to 45c, all excluding GST. At our illustrative 1,320 minutes a month, answering every call costs about A$7,000 to A$7,800 a year.
Do I have to tell callers I am using AI or recording the call?
Tell them both. The OAIC says businesses should update privacy policies and notifications with clear information about AI use, and that chatbots should be clearly identified. For recording, state and territory surveillance laws differ: NSW, the ACT, SA and WA generally need all parties' consent. The conservative approach is a clear notice at the start of every call. This is general information, not legal advice.
Can an offshore receptionist cover Australian business hours?
Yes, on a shifted roster. Manila is three hours behind Sydney during daylight saving, so about 6am to 3pm in Manila covers a Sydney 9am to 6pm day. A South Africa-based agent's ordinary day lands in the Australian evening, which suits after-hours cover. A remote receptionist cannot greet walk-ins, so keep in-person reception local.
What is the best way to combine an AI receptionist and a person?
Let AI answer after hours and when the desk is busy, take the name, number, reason and urgency, and say it is AI. Offer a route to a person, set urgent words to alert the owner at once, and have a person return complaints first. Start with a month of overflow only, then compare answered calls and complaints before changing the desk.
About the author
Nick, Co-Founder of Pear Tree, leads sales, partnerships and business development. Pear Tree connects Australian and New Zealand businesses directly with vetted offshore professionals from the Philippines and South Africa, with no agency middleman.